Skip to main content

PROPER PERSPECTIVE : All those stories you are reading about China's economy surpassing America's are wrong

There are actually a bunch of measures that say the opposite.

(AFP/Getty Images)

Is China about to leapfrog the United States to become the world's biggest economy? That's what all the headlines this week would have you believe.

But they're wrong.

The International Comparison Program, a statistical project coordinated by the World Bank, has published a report comparing the relative size of 199 economies using so-called purchasing power parity (PPP). 

What caught the media's attention was this figure buried on page 81 of the 92-page report: China was 87 percent of the size of the United States in 2011, compared with 43 percent in 2005 when the study was last conducted.

The big increase was partly due to a change in methodology and also the fact that China's economy has been growing at a faster pace.

Various reports predicted the Asian powerhouse would overtake America as the world's No. 1 economy in purchasing power terms as early as this year — much sooner than many had expected. 

What some reports failed to mention, or underplayed, is that PPP is only one way to measure the size of an economy — and it's not 100 percent accurate. The IPC admitted that its own data had a margin of error of 15 percent. 

But let's back up a bit.

 What is PPP? 

PPP seeks to show what money can buy in different countries.

"Tourists from rich countries intuitively reflect on PPP when they visit poor ones and buy dinner, thinking, 'Geez, my dollar goes farther here,'" wrote the Wall Street Journal.


When this benchmark is used to compare the size of economies, developing countries tend to do well because costs are much lower than in the developed world. 

The WSJ again:

"As costs are much higher in the industrialized world, especially for nontraded goods, comparisons of GDP by PPP exchange rates tend to boost the relative size of poorer nations’ economies. In essence, money goes further in the developing world." 

So the fact that China's purchasing power is hard on the heels of the United States doesn't tell the whole story. Even China has rejected the findings of the ICP survey, expressing reservations about the methodology.

"It does bring home the sheer size of the Chinese economy, in the services and goods and that people in China are producing," said Mark Williams, an economist for London-based Capital Economics.

"Where it falls short is that it doesn't really tell us about China's economic standing relative to the rest of the world.

"When it comes to China's purchasing power abroad, we need to look at the figures adjusted for market exchange rates."

Comparing countries by the size of their economies is always problematic whatever measure you use. Figures can be skewed by exchange rates and even the very definition of GDP. But it's useful to look at what other economic measures are telling us, even with their own particular shortcomings. And based on all those other indicators, China doesn't look quite so hot.

Here are some examples:

Value of GDP

The value of the US economy in 2012 was more than $16 trillion, almost double the size of China's, according to the World Bank.

GDP per capita

On a per capita basis, the United States leaves China in the dust. World Bank statistics show US GDP per capita in 2012 was $51,749, compared with $6,091 in China. 

ICP data on a per capita basis

The ICP's own data, on a per capita basis, shows China is still a very poor country — it ranks 99th. The United States sits in the 12th spot, reflecting its higher productivity and relative wealth.

Overall prosperity

The Legatum Prosperity Index, which looks at income and wellbeing, ranked the United States 11th in 2013. China was way down the list at 51. 

Popular posts from this blog


While "Flavor" is very subjective, and each country that grows mangoes is very nationalistic, these are the mango varieties that are the most sought after around the world because of sweetnesss (Brix) and demand.

The Chaunsa has a Brix rating in the 22 degree level which is unheard of!
Carabao claims to be the sweetest mango in the world and was able to register this in the Guiness book of world records.
Perhaps it is time for a GLOBAL taste test ???

In alphabetical order by Country....



Alphonso (mango)
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Alphonso (हापुस Haapoos in Marathi, હાફુસ in Gujarati, ಆಪೂಸ್ Aapoos in Kannada) is a mango cultivar that is considered by many[who?] to be one of the best in terms of sweetness, richness and flavor. 

It has considerable shelf life of a week after it is ripe making it exportable. 

It is also one of the most expensive kinds of mango and is grown mainly in Kokan region of western India.

 It is in season April through May and the fruit wei…

INDIA 2016 : Mango production in state likely to take a hit this year

TNN | May 22, 2016, 12.32 PM IST

Mangaluru: Vagaries of nature is expected to take a toll on the production of King of Fruits - Mango - in Karnataka this year. A combination of failure of pre-monsoon showers at the flowering and growth stage and spike in temperature in mango growing belt of the state is expected to limit the total production of mango to an estimated 12 lakh tonnes in the current season as against 14 lakh tonnes in the last calendar year.

However, the good news for fruit lovers is that this could see price of mangoes across varieties decrease marginally by 2-3%. This is mainly on account of 'import' of the fruit from other mango-growing states in India, said M Kamalakshi Rajanna, chairperson, Karnataka State Mango Development and Marketing Corporation Ltd.

Karnataka is the third largest mango-growing state in India after Uttar Pradesh and Maharashtra.

Inaugurating a two-day Vasanthotsava organized by Shivarama Karantha Pilikula Nisargadhama and the Corporation at P…

Mangoes date back 65 million years according to research ...

Experts at the Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeobotany (BSIP) here have traced the origin of mango to the hills of Meghalaya, India from a 65 million year-old fossil of a mango leaf. 

The earlier fossil records of mango (Mangifera indica) from the Northeast and elsewhere were 25 to 30 million years old. The 'carbonized leaf fossil' from Damalgiri area of Meghalaya hills, believed to be a mango tree from the peninsular India, was found by Dr R. C. Mehrotra, senior scientist, BSIP and his colleagues. 

After careful analysis of the fossil of the mango leaf and leaves of modern plants, the BISP scientist found many of the fossil leaf characters to be similar to mangifera.

An extensive study of the anatomy and morphology of several modern-day species of the genus mangifera with the fossil samples had reinforced the concept that its centre of origin is Northeast India, from where it spread into neighbouring areas, says Dr. Mehrotra. 

The genus is believed to have disseminated into neighb…